| نویسندگان | فاطمه برزگری بندکوکی,محمد احترام,فاطمه پناهی,SaadSh. Sammen,Faridah BintiOthman,AhmedEL-Shafie |
| نشریه | J HYDROL |
| شماره صفحات | 1 |
| شماره مجلد | 587 |
| ضریب تاثیر (IF) | 4.405 |
| نوع مقاله | Full Paper |
| تاریخ انتشار | 2020-08-30 |
| رتبه نشریه | علمی - پژوهشی |
| نوع نشریه | الکترونیکی |
| کشور محل چاپ | ایران |
| نمایه نشریه | JCR |
چکیده مقاله
The overall quality of Groundwater (GW) is important, primarily because it determines the suitability of water
for drinking, irrigation, and domestic purposes. In this study, the adaptive fuzzy interface system (ANFIS),
support vector machines (SVMs), and artificial neural network (ANN) models were employed for predicting the
total dissolved solids of aquifers. The moth flam optimization, cat swarm optimization (CSO), particle swarm
optimization (PSO), shark algorithm (SA), grey wolf optimization (GWO), and gravitational search algorithm
(GSA) were used to train the ANFIS, SVM, and ANN models. The data were collected from Yazd plain (Iran) to
predict the Total Dissolved Solids (TDS). The principal component analysis was used to determine the most
appropriate inputs for predicting TDS. The hybrid ANFIS-MFO improved the accuracy of RMSE (roo mean square
error) over the ANN-MFO and SVM-MFO models by 1.4% and 3.8%, respectively. It was also observed that the
SVM model had the least NSE (Nash Sutcliffe efficiency) value among all the models. Unlike the standalone
ANFIS, the multilayer perceptron (MLP), and SVMs models, the hybrid ANFIS, ANN, and SVM demonstrated high
accuracy in the training and testing phase, so that in the optimal hybrid model, ANFIS-MFO, values of mean
absolute error (MAE), Nash Sutcliff efficiency (NSE), and percent bias (PBIAS) were 2.21 (mg/lit), 0.94, 0.15,
2.981 (mg/lit), 0.93, and 0.18, respectively. The ANFIS-MFO was also seen to further enhance the RMSE by
approximately 3% and 7%, as compared to the ANN-MFO and SVM-MFO. This study also aims to investigate the
temporal variability TDS using innovative trend analysis (ITA). The TDS value of < 1800 (mg/lit) indicates a
decreasing trend, while a medium TDS value (2000 mg/lit < TDS < 2800 mg/lit) does not have a significant
trend. The high TDS values (TDS > 3000 mg/lit) indicate an increasing trend. In this study, the ANFIS-MFO and
ANFIS-CSO models showed superior performance over the other models; hence, indicates significant implication
in their application for other water resources and hydrological variables.